Everyone always assumed that the Beatles went into the studio to record Abbey Road, expecting it to be their last album…and it was. HOWEVER, in 2019 a tape was found of a meeting between John, Paul and George that was recorded so Ringo (who was in the hospital at the time) could hear the conversation. The subject? John Lennon wanted to record another Beatles album.
The date was September 8, 1969, two weeks before the release of Abbey Road. “Ringo – you can’t be here, but this is so you can hear what we’re discussing,” Lennon says into a portable tape recorder, and he seemed to steer the conversation. He suggested that he, Paul and George should contribute four songs each to the album, and Ringo could have two “if he wants them.” Paul immediately took issue with the suggestion, saying (right in front of George) “I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good.” Harrison calmly replied, “That’s a matter of taste. All down the line, people have liked my songs.” Lennon then turned the tables on Paul, saying that no one wanted to record Maxwell’s Silver Hammer for Abbey Road, but Paul simply replied that he recorded it because he liked it.
John also mentioned that the whole Lennon/McCartney myth should be laid to rest, as they had not been collaborating for quite some time. They should get individual songwriting credit.
So it got me to thinking – what songs would be on the next Beatles album? There are hundreds of people speculating that very subject, but I tried to give some serious thought before I just picked my favorite Beatles solo tunes.
First off, I think George Martin would decline to produce the album. Harrison and Lennon had started working with Phil Spector, and Paul was producing his own material. Plus the Apple Studio that Geoff Emerick was building was nearing completion, and the Beatles were really excited about recording whenever they wanted. So I envision an album where each track was produced by different people, and as a result would not flow as nicely as a typical Beatles album. But I doubt the fabs would have considered that. They just wanted to do this one on their own.
What would the title be? I went back to titles that were being considered before Abbey Road was chosen. Paul wanted to call the album Everest and fly to Tibet for a photo shoot. Other titles considered were All Good Children Go To Heaven, Inclinations and Turn Ups. However, both Mal Evans’ diary and Geoff Emerick mention the name Four In The Bar as a strong consideration, so that’s the title I went with.
I also developed cover art…pretty random, really but I think it came out pretty well. So now to choose the tracks that would be on the album – four each from John, Paul and George, and two from Ringo. Would there be hits? Of course – it’s a Beatles album, and by that point they were still pretty competitive with each other as far as songwriting. So I didn’t choose many album tracks. I’m listing them here, and including my reasons for choosing them. If you’re building a SPOTIFY playlist, you should find McCartney’s version of Come And Get It on the third anthology disc.
The Beatles: Four In The Bar
Side One
1-Another Day – Paul had suggested this song as far back as the Let It Be sessions, but it didn’t make it on to the album. He ended up recording it with Linda for the Ram sessions, and it ended up being his first solo single…a good place to start.
2-Instant Karma! – After writing this song when travelling with Yoko in Denmark, John was anxious to get back to Apple Studios to record it. He called both George Harrisoin and Phil Spector (who Allen Klein had already hired to complete the Let It Be album) and said, “Come over to Apple quick! I’ve written a monster.” It was recorded while John was still officially a member of the Beatles.
3-It Don’t Come Easy – This would be one of Ringo’s two songs on the album. He started writing it as far back as 1968, and always said he was good at writing two verses and a chorus (sometimes that’s all you need, Ringo) but had trouble finishing songs. His friend George Harrison finished the song for him, but gave Ringo full writing credit…then produced it for him.
4-Beware of Darkness – I chose all of the George Harrison selections for this album from his epic All Things Must Pass album, mainly because he had SO many songs saved up. I may have chosen this one because it’s a favorite of mine, because there is no real Beatle connection. In fact, it was one of the last songs he wrote for ATMP. NOTE: Even though My Sweet Lord was his first hit, I didn’t include it on this album for two reasons: I felt George was anticipating a solo career and wanted to save the song for himself, and I feel like Paul and John would find it “too preachy.”
5-Imagine – Even though it wasn’t recorded officially until 1971, Lennon started writing this song during the Let It Be sessions. Maybe he just wasn’t far enough along with it, or like George, maybe he was saving it for his own solo career. But I feel like John felt that if there was going to be a hit on the album, it was going to be his song…so that may have pushed him to finish it for inclusion on this album.
6-Awaiting On You All – While My Sweet Lord may have been considered “too preachy,” Harrison was all about expounding his spiritual beliefs at this point, and I feel like this song is not quite as “in your face” as MSL. Plus, it’s a very up tempo song that’s a good follow up to the slow, dirge-like Imagine (sorry, I know most people love the song, but it’s never been one of my favorites).
7-Back Seat of My Car – Paul first introduced this song to the band during the Get Back/Let It Be sessions, but I’m sure John hated it (there always has to be one Paul song per Beatles album that Lennon hated). It’s such a Paul song, isn’t it? McCartney eventually used the song to end his Ram album.
Side Two
1-Maybe I’m Amazed – Again, Paul and John may have been competing for hits, and Paul may have felt this would have a good shot. He wrote the song in 1969, and even though most of his first solo album was recorded at his farm, he recorded this one at Abbey Road Studios, playing all of the instruments himself.
2-Jealous Guy – John initially demoed this song in 1968 when the Beatles were putting together their self-titled double album known as The White Album. The original title was Child of Nature. Not sure of the connection of that title to the song (maybe the lyrics were different), but it’s a great ballad by Lennon.
3-What Is Life – Time to pick up the tempo again, with a GREAT George Harrison song, one of my favorites. George wrote this song in 1969, and originally thought it would be a perfect, catchy pop song for his friend, Billy Preston, to record. When he visited Preston in the studio (he was recording That’s The Way God Planned It) he found that Billy was working on funkier material. So instead of presenting it to the Beatles, he tucked it away for his own use.
4-Come And Get It – Lennon probably didn’t like this one, either. Paul introduced it to the band during the Abbey Road sessions, recording all the instruments and vocals himself. It didn’t make the album, and roadie Mal Evans had signed Badfinger to Apple Records, and they were looking for a single. Paul was asked to provide three songs for the movie “The Magic Christian,” and he decided he didn’t have time for it. So he gave the job to Badfinger, and gave them the demo to Come And Get It, telling the band to make it “exactly like this demo” and they would have a hit…which they did.
5-Give Me Some Truth – Lennon started this tune when the band was in India in 1968, and the band took a stab at recording it during the Get Back/Let It Be sessions. For whatever reason, it wasn’t included in that project. I would think that out of four Lennon contributions for this album, only one (Instand Karma!) had any grit to it, and John would want to make his political statement with this song.
6-Isn’t It A Pity – A great Harrison song that was presented, according to historians, for FOUR different Beatles albums, starting with Revolover. Harrison wanted it included on Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, and later on The Beatles (The White Album) and finally on Get Back/Let It Be. When putting together songs for All Things Must Pass, George wanted to include this song so much that he put two different versions of the song on the three-album set. I’ve included version two for this project.
7-Early 1970 – What a perfect way to finish off the album! A fun little song from Ringo where he describes each member of the band. It’s sure to end your listening experience with a smile.
Well, there you have it. I’m sure you’re already putting together an alternate version in your head, as well you should. I hope you enjoy “Four In The Bar.” I’ve listened to it several times so far, and I must admit – I’d buy it!